SHARE ON: |
| |
| |
 |
 |
|
|
In the midst of a fourth wave, Canadian hospitals are pulling out all the stops to prevent further outbreaks of COVID-19.
After much of the country’s hospitals moved to implement mandatory vaccine policies for employees, a growing number are turning their attention to visitors and occasional care staff, requiring they too show proof of vaccination before being allowed to enter hospital facilities.
It’s a move that has stirred yet another pandemic-era debate for Canadians and ethicists alike, particularly considering the delicate and sometimes life-altering business that happens behind hospital doors.
“I think of all the places that we need to show proof of vaccinations, this is one of them,” Elizabeth Bardon, COVID incident commander at Kingston Health Sciences Centre in Ontario, told CTV National News.
“People who come to hospital are not coming by choice, they are very ill and right now, our patients are sicker than theyve ever been... we have a special duty of care to make sure that they dont get infected with something else while theyre here.”
Starting Oct. 22, Kingston Health Sciences Centre will require that all registered family visitors who are coming to visit inpatients be fully vaccinated and show proof of vaccination before entering the hospital.
The hospital joins several other Greater Toronto Area health centres, including the University Health Network (UHN), and hospitals in Quebec in implementing these new rules.
In B.C., visitor vaccination requirements first adopted in long-term care homes will expand to acute care and community care visitors on Oct. 26. Meanwhile in Alberta, where hospitals were hit hard by the fourth wave of the virus, calls to adopt a similar policy are growing louder.
From an epidemiological standpoint, ethicists say the policy is in line with hospitals’ main priority: keeping patients safe.
But looking at the topic from a compassionate standpoint is where it gets tricky.
“I have to admit from an ethical and human perspective, this is potentially the hardest context in which we are requiring vaccine proof because when are we more vulnerable when a loved one is in the hospital? When else do we have the incentive or desperate need to be there for a loved one,” Vardit Ravitsky, professor of bioethics at the University of Montreal, told CTV National News.
“We need to keep in mind how sensitive how this requirement is because it touches on families at their most difficult moments, in their most vulnerable situations.”
Ravitsky notes that hospitals should make exemptions for those who are medically unable to receive a vaccine, but adds that there should be compassionate exemptions in place under certain circumstances.
“For example, you’re accompanying someone into the ER and they need help… you’re accompanying your child,” she said. “If you’re accompanying a woman in labour, if you’re accompanying someone who is actively dying, at the very end of their life, or if you’re an essential visitor, which means you’re providing physical care for the visitor.”
At the same time, Ravitsky agrees that hospitals should limit the entry of those unvaccinated by choice to those very limited situations and require additional safety measures from those visitors if exemptions are approved, such as providing rapid testing, protective equipment, and limiting the amount of time spent with patients.
“Even if it only lasts a few weeks or months, we have to be aware of the human need and tragic nature of some situations and create enough space for nuance in the way that we implement this idea,” Ravitsky explained.
Hospitals like Kingston Health Sciences say they have provided some wiggle room to unvaccinated visitors by announcing these policies in advance and say, overall, the reaction has been supportive thus far.
“Our goal throughout the pandemic has been to really balance safety and compassion and weve worked really hard to do that,” Bardon said.
“We dont want to go backwards. We want to continue to be in a position that we can open carefully and slowly as we go, rather than having to do a shutdown because of an outbreak where were actually excluding more people from the hospital.”
|
 |
|
 |
|
 |
|
 |
2 am |
| 7 ℃ |
| BROKEN CLOUDS |
WIND: SSW 19 KM/H
GUSTING TO 48 KM/H |
|
|
|
3 am |
| 7 ℃ |
| BROKEN CLOUDS |
WIND: SW 19 KM/H
GUSTING TO 43 KM/H |
|
|
|
4 am |
| 7 ℃ |
| BROKEN CLOUDS |
WIND: SW 16 KM/H
GUSTING TO 44 KM/H |
|
|
|
5 am |
| 8 ℃ |
| OVERCAST CLOUDS |
WIND: WSW 18 KM/H
GUSTING TO 47 KM/H |
|
|
|
6 am |
| 10 ℃ |
| OVERCAST CLOUDS |
WIND: WSW 24 KM/H
GUSTING TO 52 KM/H |
|
|
|
7 am |
| 11 ℃ |
| OVERCAST CLOUDS |
WIND: WNW 27 KM/H
GUSTING TO 49 KM/H |
|
|
|
8 am |
| 5 ℃ |
| OVERCAST CLOUDS |
WIND: WNW 26 KM/H
GUSTING TO 50 KM/H |
|
|
 |
9 am |
| 5 ℃ |
| OVERCAST CLOUDS |
WIND: NW 23 KM/H
GUSTING TO 43 KM/H |
|
|
|
|
TODAY |
HIGH OF 11 ℃
LOW OF 1 ℃ |
| OVERCAST CLOUDS |
|
|
 |
SATURDAY |
HIGH OF 2 ℃
LOW OF -3 ℃ |
| CLEAR SKY |
|
|
|
SUNDAY |
HIGH OF 4 ℃
LOW OF -3 ℃ |
| BROKEN CLOUDS |
|
|
 |
MONDAY |
HIGH OF 3 ℃
LOW OF -3 ℃ |
| SCATTERED CLOUDS |
|
|
|
TUESDAY |
HIGH OF 3 ℃
LOW OF -2 ℃ |
| BROKEN CLOUDS |
|
|
|
WEDNESDAY |
HIGH OF 6 ℃
LOW OF 1 ℃ |
| BROKEN CLOUDS |
|
|
 |
THURSDAY |
HIGH OF 3 ℃
LOW OF 0 ℃ |
| LIGHT SNOW |
|
|
 |
FRIDAY |
HIGH OF 3 ℃
LOW OF -3 ℃ |
| FEW CLOUDS |
|
|
|
|
|
|
 |
 |
KIP MOORE
MIDNIGHT SLOW DANCE
02:01 AM |
|
 |
THOMAS RHETT
OLD TRICKS
01:58 AM |
|
 |
PETRIC
SINGLE PROBLEM
01:55 AM |
|
 |
BRANTLEY GILBERT
ME AND MY HOUSE
01:51 AM |
|
 |
BRELAND
CRACKS
01:48 AM |
|
 |
BROTHERS OSBORNE
BREAK MINE
01:40 AM |
|
 |
MITCHELL TENPENNY
WOKE UP IN A DREAM
01:37 AM |
|
 |
DREW BALDRIDGE
BIG PRAYERS
01:34 AM |
|
 |
OLD DOMINION
WATER MY FLOWERS
01:30 AM |
|
 |
CARRIE UNDERWOOD
SMOKE BREAK
01:27 AM |
|
 
 |
